November 12, 2007

An interesting claim regarding BI openness

Analyst conference calls about merger announcements are generally pretty boring. Indeed, the companies involved tend to feel they are legally barred from saying anything interesting, by mandate of both the antitrust regulators and the SEC.

Still, such calls are joyful events, full of strategic happy talk. If one is really lucky, there may a virtuouso tap dancing exhibition as well. On today’s IBM/Cognos call, Cognos CEO Rob Ashe was asked whether he thought Cognos’ independence or lack thereof was as important today as he said it was after SAP announced its BOBJ takeover. Without missing a beat, he responded that there were two kinds of openness:

  1. Database openness (not important)
  2. ERP/business process openness (indeed important)

Hmm. I’m not so sure I agree. To begin with, there aren’t just two major points of potential integration. There’s also a whole lot of middleware: obviously data integration, but also app servers, portals, and query execution acceleration as well.

Let me spell out that last point a little bit. NetWeaver has been SAP’s integrated BI/app server. Oracle’s app server has data caching built in. Crystal Reports had a custom app server when Business Objects acquired it. BI is increasing integrated with portals, and portals are integrated with app servers and other middleware.

And that’s just today. Futures include a whole new technology stack to revolutionize dashboards, with better integration of “alerting” UIs (on- and off-screen alike) as part of the package.

Also, when query resolution goes memory-centric, the boundaries between BI/report servers and DBMS get really blurred. E.g., I’m not sure there’s a huge fundamental difference between what ParAccel sells today and what SAP has long described as a reasonable (albeit very hypothetical) path for the evolution of BI Accelerator.

And by the way: I really don’t think that BI/business process integration is far enough along for any kind of closedness in that regard to much matter — more’s the pity.

So on the whole, I think I don’t agree with Rob Ashe’s analysis on that particular issue.

In fact, I think one of the most exciting things about this merger is the potential technological integration among many different IBM product lines. In saying that, I’m looking a loooong way down the road — but eventually it could be very cool indeed.

Technorati Tags: ,

Keep getting great research about business intelligence, data warehousing, and other analytic technologies. Get a FREE subscription by RSS or email!


One Response to “An interesting claim regarding BI openness”

  1. 생활지혜 on June 27th, 2008 9:41 pm

    비만해소를 위한 식습관 10계명 !!

    1. 식사시간은 적어도 20∼30분으로 하라.

    2.한번에 20번 이상 십어라.

    3.저녁식사는 오후 8시 이전에 끝내라.

    4.식사중 TV나 신문을 보지마라.

    5.지정된 장소에서 식사하라.

    6.정해진 시간에 식사하라.

    7.’홀로 식사’를 피하라.

    8.야채, 해초류를 즐겨라.

    9.아침식사를 거르지 말고 세끼 식사량을 균등히 하라.

    10.과식을 많이 하는 사람은 물 2∼3컵을 마신 뒤 식사하라.


Leave a Reply

Feed: DBMS (database management system), DW (data warehousing), BI (business intelligence), and analytics technology Subscribe to the Monash Research feed via RSS or email:


Search our blogs and white papers

Monash Research blogs

User consulting

Building a short list? Refining your strategic plan? We can help.

Vendor advisory

We tell vendors what's happening -- and, more important, what they should do about it.

Monash Research highlights

Learn about white papers, webcasts, and blog highlights, by RSS or email.